How valuable are creature manatokens?

Commander Deck Help forum

Posted on Sept. 11, 2019, 10:49 a.m. by Schadowpop

Dear people from Tapped Out,

I have been very excited about constructing an Eldrazi Tribal deck. This will be my second deck, I will take a considerate amount of time to carefully construct this investment.

I have come as far to construct a reasonable mana base (still up for change if needed) and a few cards to help me through early game. I still want to include cards like Explosive Vegetation and Descendants' Path .

I have defined a strategy:

  • Early game: ramp mana, cast Animar, Soul of Elements
  • Mid game: protect Animar, cast small creatures and tutor big ones or fix card advantage
  • End game: cast the big creatures, end it.

My question arose when I was evaluating cards like: Drowner of Hope , Rapacious One and Brood Monitor , which create manatokens. These are all cards with CMC ≥5. Thus I consider these cards castable mid-game. According to my strategy I want to create manaramp (e.g. manatokens) earlygame, not midgame

This conflict made me think to myself: How valuable is creating tokens? What is your guys' opinions, are these tokencreators worth keeping in my deck and should I change strategy or do I just toss em out?

All feedback is welcome! I'd love to hear your opinion.

Deck:


Eldrazi Tribal

Commander / EDH* Schadowpop

SCORE: 2 | 41 VIEWS


Caerwyn says... #2

This thread was moved to a more appropriate forum (auto-generated comment)

September 11, 2019 11:47 a.m.

Please login to comment