Comments View Archive
I'd recommend Hagra Diabolist over Sea Gate Loremaster. SGL doesn't survive the bolt test (which is an important test in modern) and doesn't draw you cards right away especially without a haste source, plus since your land count is low and you don't want to go much past 3 on Aether Vial then he doesn't seem that great. Hagra Diabolist though you can ping people for the last few points of damage by the time you get there, especially if you get out fast enough. Better yet, Kalastria Healer might be good against control due to board wipes and because they don't target, unlike HD. CoCo is amazing but you may also consider Chord of Calling to find someone in response to a board wipe. I'd also consider Abrupt Decay as it is very useful. I also suggest that you play fetches with relevant shocklands if those too are within your budget; the ETB tapped lands are not what you want to be doing because that extra turn is much more important than your colors, though you could play Mana Confluence and City of Brass if you were so inclined since you have some amount of life gain and the ability to get out very quickly.
March 15, 2017 6:40 p.m.
March 15, 2017 11:29 p.m.
March 16, 2017 2:57 a.m.
halimar excavator is literally a do nothing until you've milled opponent out entirely.
March 16, 2017 8:32 a.m.
which goes incredibly fast, believe me. Captain's Claws and another ally per turn with 4-5 allies on the board, you do the math. always brought my opponents to rage, especially if 2 of em are on the board. and that's why the deck is flagged combo and not aggro ;)
March 16, 2017 9:36 a.m.
I agree with al5464, the excavators are a problem because it splits your focus, you are using 3 slots to use excavator when you could be using them to pressure your opponents life, a survivalist and 2 shapeshifters for example
Ask yourself, what will help you win more often, an excavator on turn 2, milling them out on turn 6/7, or a survivalist racing in for a turn 5/6 win
I'm not saying milling with excavator isn't a great plan, but you aren't committed. you're deck is trying to do 2 things and it means it will struggle to do either very well
April 11, 2017 6:21 p.m.
@TallGreg, first of all, ty for your feedback. But I guess I stick with the current setup. This deck is labeled combo, and that's exactly what it does. Hada Freeblade, Kazandu Blademaster and Oran-Rief Survivalist sure are part of the aggro-path which I follow if there's room for it, but Halimar Excavator, Ondu Cleric and Hagra Diabolist are taking over if a game lasts longer leaving the scaling aggro creatures as useful blockers. And suddenly they all give me the freedom to let a game take longer.
In a usual game I'm able to deal dmg within the first 2-3 turns with the fast paced allies. As soon my opponent reached head to head I can lay back and let the triggers of the allies do the work. As soon Kabira Evangel appears, game is over anyway most of the times.
I did a ton of playtesting with this one and it works constant and reliable, so I see no benefit to go fulltard on aggro which would make me vulnerable in other spots ;)
April 12, 2017 4:46 a.m.
tschiller It's obviously your deck, but I can tell you the reason a long game is seen as an inevitable conclusion is because you lack the threat density to win the game with your aggro.
I have no problem with Hagra Diabolist and Kabira Evangel as finishers, but they simply do not synergize well with Halimar Excavator. There is a reason you never see a mill deck with an aggro package or a creature deck with a mill package.
April 12, 2017 9:38 a.m.
Let's agree to disagree, my winrate just tells me a different story, physical and on mtgo :) But thx for your last advice, this combo seems interesting! If I fiddle around with the deck next time, I'll consider these 2 cards, so took em to the maybe's.
April 12, 2017 10:45 a.m.
I would be interested in playing against you on MODO. My username there and here is MadKat. It would be cool to see your deck in action.
April 13, 2017 12:51 a.m.
You neeeed Return to the Ranks and 4 Halimar Excavator. You can go off and mill an amazing amount of cards with Return to the Ranks, excavator, and company. i would bump up these combo pieces to 4 each and cut some of the "meh" allies like the Oran-Rief Survivalist, Diabolist (5 mana?). Also, the shapeshifter should be at 4 because it is practically any ally you have which is amazing and it basically gives you multiple copies of the combo piece Halimar Excavator.
April 25, 2017 8:05 p.m.
There's a few suggestions I can make based off the 4-color Ally deck I use that is very similar to this.
Since you can produce all five colors, I really recommend Unified Front and Bring to Light. Bring to Light can tutor for any of the nonland, nonartifact cards in this deck and play them for free. Unified Front can get you 4 Ally ETB triggers. The Cavern of Souls and Ally Encampments won't give you colored mana for them though, which may limit their usability.
I'm thinking about using Descendants' Path in my Ally deck, but haven't gotten around to adding them yet. It's a great Turn 3 drop that can help you ramp your boardstate and get more triggers.
I'm really surprised you don't have Eerie Interlude. It provides your Allies with instant-speed evasion while also giving you a solid win-con for 3 Mana if you have the right Allies on the field (Excavators, Diabolists, etc.) Since they all see each other, they'll all trigger each other on re-entry. For example, if you flicker two Excavators, a Druid, a Freeblade, and a Diabolist, you can mill for a total of 50 cards, bleed someone for 25 life, and get 5 +1/+1 counters on your Freeblade.
Panharmonicon is another card that will do you a lot of good. 4 mana seems like a lot in a tribal deck like this, but the ability to double all your ETB triggers is far better than playing one more Ally.
Rite of Replication can also tilt the scales in your favor (and can be tutored with Bring to Light if you have 5 colors). Kicking it on an Excavator or Diabolist usually means the game is over.
With how aggressive and destructive Modern is, I'd really recommend you have some recursion. March from the Tomb is nice, but so is Rally the Ancestors. Imagine milling half your library with an Excavator, only to cast Rally the Ancestors for 4, putting all the milled 2- and 1-drop Allies on the field, effectively ending the game.
Do you get use out of the Kabira Evangel? I always thought the ability was nice, but a little limited since its effect is only temporary.
Since you only have 18 lands, consider adding a fourth Druid to help you 'get there' with mana.
April 26, 2017 6:50 p.m.
Here is the deck I use that is really similar to this one: Turn 4, Mill 600 Cards Please...
April 26, 2017 6:58 p.m.
Please login to comment
|Date added||1 year|
|Last updated||3 weeks|
This deck is Modern legal.
|Tokens||1/1 Kor Ally|
|Folders||random, Z - Decks I Like, Physical, Looks Fun, decks|
|Top rank||#14 on 2017-03-17|