Kickin' it Old School

Commander / EDH Shimtalia

SCORE: 1 | 7 COMMENTS | 228 VIEWS | IN 1 FOLDER


Back to doing "periodic updates" —Jan. 14, 2019

So, it’s been a while, sorry…Keeping 34 Commander decks up to date is hard, keeping my lists of new cards coming in and out and looking at new sets of cards and updating online lists for the three of you who ever looked is harder still. Something had to fall by the wayside, sadly, it was Tapped Out, but I am back again, after unknown periods of time (literally, I don’t remember when my last update was) with the following:

IN: Broken Bond, Death's Presence, Mountain, Seeds of Renewal, Shape of the Wiitigo, Spire Garden, Strionic Resonator, Stonewood Invocation

OUT: Forestx2, Keen Sense, Momentous Fall, Monstrous Onslaught, Rishkar's Expertise, Scorching Lava, Sunbird's Invocation

ACQUIRE AND TRY OUT (including new from Ravnica Allegiance): Gruul Locket, Keen Sense, Momentous Fall, Monstrous Onslaught, Rishkar's Expertise, Sunbird's Invocation

Hi! I'm trying to optimize mine too. I have played with it some few games now, I think he just needs to stick around to be able to do what is intended. So I use spells like Inspiring Call and Heroic Intervention. I'm still in the process of improving my deck so I don't know what to suggest for now.

May 12, 2018 8:58 a.m. Edited.

Shimtalia says... #2

Thanks for the comment! Sticking around is why I added thing like Swiftfoot Boots, but more may be necessary...

Something to ponder!

May 12, 2018 10:24 a.m.

DogKnight156 says... #3

Agreed with Pandavs, I'd also stick an isochron scepter in here. Throw blossoming defense, inspiring call, heroic intervention, etc on it, and bam. Safety stick.

May 13, 2018 11:19 p.m.

ersatz_olorin says... #4

Everflowing Chalice acts as ramp and a kicker trigger

Comet Storm can be a game winner, or a board wipe, but it's also a kicker spell

Mold Shambler is removal and a trigger

Molten Disaster is an uncounterable trigger/ board wipe

Verdeloth the Ancient creates a big board with enough mana

A lot of bad kicker spells out there, but these are all semi playable.

I'd stay away from +1/+1 stuff because you're missing some crucial cards in white.

One thing that might be interesting with this commander is Cloudstone Curio or Erratic Portal. Bounce and replay kicker creatures into the win.

May 16, 2018 12:01 a.m.

Shimtalia says... #5

Thank-you all for your comments and suggestions. A few of the suggestions, well, I thought they were in there already! So here is the updates:

IN

Blossoming Defense - Cloudstone Curio - Everflowing Chalice - Inspiring Call - Molten Disaster - Mortal's Resolve - Saproling Infestation - Withstand Death - Forestx2

OUT

Champion's Helm - Deathforge Shaman - Hunger of the Howlpack - Kavu Titan - Pouncing Wurm - Primeval Bounty - Verix Bladewing - Mountainx3

May 16, 2018 2:54 p.m.

Shimtalia says... #6

Yeah, So...In the last 24 hours, I did a bunch of work on this deck, proxied a bunch of it up, took it for a spin in front of a goldfish bowl, and I discovered I needed to make some changes.

For one, I had too many kicker spells. They are easily the weakest part of the deck, vital and important that they may be. Two, I needed some card draw. Three, well, just some other thoughts that came to me while I was working...

In:

Blood Clock - Breath of Darigaaz - Chandra's Ignition - Decimate - Keen Sense - Loxodon Warhammer - Momentous Fall - Opal Palace - Rishkar's Expertise - Sunbird's Invocation - Vigor(I want to try this, though it is the only expensive card I don't already own for the deck, it's worth more than the rest of what I don't have combined...)

Out:

Blessings of Nature(too many +1/+1 too fast makes too much of a target) - Cloudstone Curio - Gnarlid Pack - Grafted Exoskeleton(yes, it's a massive kill enabler, but also a massive kill me sign) - Grunn, the Lonely King - Horned Kavu - Increasing Savagery(see Blessings) - Skitter of Lizards - Thicket Elemental - Mountain - Forest

May 16, 2018 11:21 p.m.

TheNocholas says... #7

Jaya Ballard and Past in Flames could help you replay cards. This could allow you to put in some loot cards to speed up your game.

May 24, 2018 3:12 p.m.