|Commander / EDH||Legal|
Printings View all
|Commander Anthology 2018 (CM2)||Rare|
|Commander 2016 (C16)||Rare|
Combos Browse all
Reveal the top ten cards of your library. Starting with the next opponent in turn order, each opponent chooses a different nonland card from among them. Put the chosen cards into your hand and the rest on the bottom of your library in a random order.
Manifold Insights Discussion
5 months ago
Oooffft Nice version!
How has Manifold Insights and Recurring Insight been working out for you? and I feel like Trickbind might be a bit too narrow don't you think could add more bounce for the combo turn cursed totem removal?
And I see you've been plagued by our "pro's" amongst the casuals jaymc1130 and Skillville, a VERY sad bunch of casuals xD Anyhow good list!
6 months ago
Stalking Vengeance and Bane of Bala Ged -> Saheeli, Sublime Artificer and Chasm Skulker --- Too many expensive 7 drops that get killed before they can do anything. Bring the curve down and add more token production
9 months ago
So, I'm not sure I'll change your mind, but I'll explain why I prefer the cards over Foresee and let you judge beyond that however you feel most comfortable. Foresee , by rule, does let you theoretically see 6 cards, but thats probably the worst case scenario for that card since that means your scry 4 is putting everything on the bottom and you are drawing blind.
Cards like Fact or Fiction and Steam Augury allow you to do 2 things. 1) you get to leave your mana up for any other instants or interactions that you can have when it is not your turn. 2) It puts you 5 cards deep into your deck at instant speed, so after resolution (in theory) you have full access to whatever pile you choose on your turn. These cards are also excellent politics cards if there is a scenario in multiplayer that everyone is way behind one player and you need to dig for an answer, you can talk your way into more favorable piles. Lastly, I understand players have the fear of not being in control of your cards, but quite a few spell slinger decks utilize their graveyards aswell as their hand for redundant value, so even though you get a 2 or 3 card split, those other cards can always be reclaimed with other effects and playing green, you have several ways to buy back cards.
Manifold Insights is a card that I like solely because it boils down to pay 3 mana, get 3 non-land cards. It is excellent in mid to late games because more often than not the worst thing you get is ramp, which in itself is pretty good.
One thing I did not mention is you probably want to add Fall of the Titans to replace one of your fireballs. Personally I don't much care for Crater's Claws . In a vacuum, its just a much better card whether you have 12 mana to do 14 damage to one target or you cast a 2 drop, have 10 mana at instant speed to 2 targets seems much stronger.
Finally, I did see the changes and do like the adds. I am a little skeptical of cutting Regrowth as that is a very strong card and is better, in my opinion, than something like Serum Visions or Ponder . Those two are great cards, but Regrowth effects in commander are much stronger than 1 mana, draw 1. Especially in the late game.
9 months ago
The curve is really only dependent on what you are trying to do ranging from storm low to reanimator high. I don't have any issues with the curve you have just was looking at not cutting a 2 (Baral) for a 4 (Jace's Sanctum).
As for cards I would cut, I mentioned Baral seems underwhelming to me. Foresee does aswell. I also don't think Niv-Mizzet does a whole lot with the amount of draw you have.
10 months ago
We already spoke about these already but I'm commenting with a couple of suggestions here so you have a list to come back to
Altar of Bone - Use it to either sacrifice or find rector. Finding rector doesn't need explaining but as a sac outlet it will be able to find spellseeker which will let you merchant scroll for dig through time and guarantee the combo kill
Recruiter of the Guard - A bit wonky but it finds rector and other bears. Decent if you're trying to up your count. Also works as part of the combo kill by finding spellseeker and initiating the chain I posted above.
Manifold Insights - We talked about this one but the main premise is that you're digging 10 and that at least a few of the hits are going to be lands. The rest will be some combination of gas or semi live draws. The worst thing your opponents will give you are dorks/ bad ramp/ or redundant looters but you only have 10 combined of all those effects in the deck so the chances are pretty low that you end up getting a grip or 3 after this. Odds are in your favor. I don't think we want this in stuff like circu but when it comes to UW, Winterblast was right again.
Intuition - Manifold Insights is basically a worse copy of this effect. Works with seasons past, rector recur, and pretty much every combo you have access to. Plus it's an instant.
The last thing to consider is the dredge stuff in conjunction with Replenish and Open the Vaults . The real issue would be one of can you get enough pieces to the yard and to be honest I'm not sure. You get some neat tech with all the bant land recur, stuff like Riftstone Portal , and potentially things like Wonder which will act as evasion for rafiq and your draw dorks. Maybe these would even be able to justify something like Survival of the Fittest coming back but it just depends on how you can play with the grave. Lands, enchantments, and artifacts are all easy and you even have some play with recurring instants and sorceries but getting creatures back is much more difficult. This paragraph is more food for thought than recommendations though as it would be near impossible to build a shell with all this without finding an entomb type effect or some sort of massive miller outside of the deck's looters or something insane like Hermit Druid or breakfast combo.
If I see any more I'll let you know
10 months ago
Absorb doesn't seem to be on flavour. How about replacing it with Manifold Insights ? It's free off your commander, you're testing your opponents (albeit with multiple choice), and you'll get three cards.
11 months ago
Nietzsky thanks for the link!
I see you play more reactive and scepter also requires different cards. I'm playing more cards that prevent scepter and the like, In the Eye of Chaos for example is specifically anti-instant tech and while it is just one card in 99 it definitely has some impact on card choices. One result is playing more proactively and not passing turns and keeping counterspells in case something important is cast. That in turn makes Teferi worse than Narset and the land untapping pretty much irrelevant. Also leads to the disenchant > negate issue...let's say I have the option of casting something or keep the mana open for negate. I would always slam down what I have and play a disenchant on my next turn IF someone has managed to play something like mana rocks or whatever instead of having to decide whether I play or keep a reaction for something that might not come (and lose a turn). Of course, there are spells that can't be dealt with on the following turn, but in the early game it's often rocks that slipped through and that I want to remove again and later my playstyle forces opponents to spend their little resources on not losing to each other's threats when I keep playing aggressively. That works better the more competitive the table is, but to be honest I wouldn't want to run into random suboptimal decks with GAAIV anyway...as I have built it now it's best against opponents that can actually do something an not just want to get value on the table. When playing online against random people I have exchanged Manifold Insights with Supreme Verdict (maybe Wrath of God, not sure if the colour requirement is better than can't be countered) because it happens more often that people just leave a game or their prog crashes and there's also the possibility of running into more creatures than I see locally.
I tried playing Personal Tutor instead of Spellseeker (or Serra Ascendant, I am playing around with changes a bit) and it feels rather good. getting MLD or a wheel is nice. got to check if the cmc restriction is worse than getting only sorceries...
On a side note, I do think that the budget has a lot of impact on how you can play stax. The game warping potential of some high priced cards is so massive that you can build around them in a way that can't be done if you need budget replacements.
11 months ago
Nietzsky I had Teferi in the deck until I accidentially sold him. He is ok but it wasn't overwhelming imo. First of all, he starts with 2 loyalty less than Narset and he takes one more +1 to ultimate. Another aspect of Teferi, that I didn't like too much, was that the untapping of lands EOT was pretty much irrelevant and his 2nd ability sets him on 1 if used immediately. Narset on the other hand could potentially use it 3 times in a row before she dies. The rebound would be used on stuff like Transmute Artifact, Timetwister, Manifold Insights, Hurkyl's Recall, Disenchant (if it's in the deck)...but more often than not I'd focus on getting Narset to 9 while drawing a few extra cards. Her costing only 2 mana with GAAIV makes her an easy play between others. I have around 13-15 instants/sorceries that make sense to rebound (obviously not counting MLD and counters).
As for the Disenchant/Counterspell question, I don't play reactively in general with this deck. It's all about slamming down the pieces as early and fast as possible and refilling the hand with strong engines...being able to keep a counter once in a while is fine, but mostly I will be destroying mana sources that have been cast before GAAIV was in play and also remove stuff that has already resolved because I spent my turn for putting more obstacles into play. Especially in the early game I don't want to hold back mana for potentially countering something, but rather play my stuff proactively and destroy what an opponent could still cast in my next turn. This is because the available proactive moves have a high potential of preventing important plays from opponents in the first place.
Spellseeker is better than merchant scroll because it's instant or sorcery and doesn't have to be blue. I don't play Merchant Scroll because there's no blue instant I'd really need that much to include a special tutor for it. As additional tutor I have put in Muddle the Mixture because cmc 2 is a lot more important to find (Cursed Totem, Rest in Piece, Gilded Drake, Sphere of Resistance, Cyclonic Rift...). Spellseeker is a really strong card in general, perfect in my Najeela and Circu deck for example, but there it gets exactly the cards I want to find most of all. Here I'm not sure about it anymore.
Chalice of the Void blocks like a third of everyone's spells so it's pretty strong. I would even say in combination with Lavinia it would shut down even more because she prevents the more expensive spells from being cast, chalice counters cmc 1 (that's what it should do) and without taxes Lavinia counters cmc 0 as well. With taxes in addition the whole board will be a big mess in which people have to think twice about which cards are even castable. I think having Lavinia in the same deck as Chalice is not bad at all...The question is just how many situations are there in which countering cmc 1 spells is bad for me too. It didn't have a negative impact on my plays before, but then I had more combo options that didn't need divining top. I would argue that putting chalice in should go along with using at least staff and probably metalworker as well in my build.
Personal Tutor is interesting and I even have one at home. There are several high impact sorceries, from Timetwister to Armageddon and having another cmc 1 tutor for these can be helpful. Catastrophe is nice because of the flexibility but 2 cmc more than the creature/lands only boardwipes is a bit much. Especially when there are Back to Basics and Winter Orb to fuck with lands as well. There's also Sunder and Mana Breach. I think instead of running more but weaker LD cards I'd rather maximise the chances of finding them when needed. timespiral as a third wheel might be really interesting, also in combination with personal tutor.
Could you link your build to compare?
Manifold Insights occurrence in decks from the last year
Commander / EDH:
All decks: 0.01%