Identity Thief


Format Legality
1v1 Commander Legal
Frontier Legal
Vintage Legal
Modern Legal
Casual Legal
Legacy Legal
Duel Commander Legal
Unformat Legal
Pauper Legal
Commander / EDH Legal

Printings View all

Set Rarity
Eldritch Moon (EMN) Rare
Promo Set (000) Rare

Combos Browse all

Identity Thief

Creature — Shapeshifter

Whenever Identity Thief attacks, you may exile another target nontoken creature. If you do, Identity Thief becomes a copy of that creature until end of turn. Return the exiled card to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next end step.

Price & Acquistion Set Price Alerts



Recent Decks

Load more

Identity Thief Discussion

MagicalHacker on Shouldn't This be BANNED?! (Medomai Primer)

1 month ago

Close, but not exactly. Here's the two ways it can be used:

  1. Play Humility or Darksteel Mutation on Medomai the Ageless while Vedalken Mastermind is out. Since Humility/Darksteel Mutation makes Medomai the Ageless able to attack on extra turns by removing all abilities, attack with Medomai the Ageless. After attacking, but before blocking is declared, activate Vedalken Mastermind or cast Capsize with buyback targeting the Darksteel Mutation or the Humility. Then blocks are declared (flying is nice), and damage is dealt, giving me an extra turn. The last step is to recast the Humility or Darksteel Mutation on Medomai the Ageless and do it all again the next turn.

  2. If I attack with Identity Thief while Medomai the Ageless is on the battlefield, I exile Medomai the Ageless until end of turn and Identity Thief becomes a copy of Medomai the Ageless until end of turn. This let's it become a copy after it attacks, so it can attack on extra turns too. After dealing damage with Identity Thief, I activate Vedalken Mastermind or cast Capsize with buyback targeting the Identity Thief so that when Medomai the Ageless returns to the battlefield at the end of the turn, I won't have to get rid of one of the creatures due to the legend rule.

MagicalHacker on Shouldn't This be BANNED?! (Medomai Primer)

2 months ago

Horde of Notions, thank you for the comment! I did add Identity Thief, but just wanted to let you know that it still needs another piece to go infinite, since Medomai enters the battlefield before Identity Thief stops being Medomai. This means that the legend rule will force you to get rid of one. Luckily, we have Capsize and Obelisk of Undoing to make the combo infinite.

Dismantling Blow is good, but I still like Disenchant more since I'm not really worried about card advantage when I play it. However, saving mana each time is worth playing Disenchant over it.

The only three drop counterspells I play are ones that also cantrip so that spending a lot of counterspells in one round does not completely empty my hand of all my answers.

Murphy77 on whats yours is mine

2 months ago

Identity Thief to bounce your own Gonti, Lord of Luxury might be a good idea.

hoardofnotions on Shouldn't This be BANNED?! (Medomai Primer)

2 months ago

Identity Thief is a combo with your commander. You'll be able to attack with it on your extra turns and turn it into your commander for infinite turns. Sorry if you've already considered this you have a lot of comments to read through lol

cmsrDPM on Still My Turn

3 months ago

If you have an Identity Thief and a Medomai the Ageless, you can take infinite turns.

Hyperalgialysis on Tokemon *Budget* Temmet EDH

3 months ago

Your maybe board looks like one awesome deck. Your main would greatly benefit from including bits of it. Regardless, if you want to keep it under $50 I will try and offer some budget options you may not have considered. Quicksilver Gargantuan is a great Clone and pairs really well with Stolen Identity. Identity Thief is awesome with etb effects. I also like Sram's Expertise, Servo Exhibition and Raise the Alarm all solid token makers. If you start seeing some value in adding more instant and sorcery spells, Talrand, The Sky Summoner and Talrand's Invocation are both solid in that type of strategy. I did see the incovation in the maybe board but if talrand makes it in the invoaction is good too. Elspeth, Knight-Errant starts to get out of price range but is so good I had to mention her. A few good board wipes are Descend upon the Sinful Planar Outburst and Planar Cleansing. The cleansing makes your opponents so sad cause it hits mana rocks too. Judge's Familiar Spiketail Hatchling Spiketail Drakeling and Spiketail Drake are all good targets for copy effects and give that extra value since they are counterspells on a stick, and they fly! One last good thing to cover would be draw. Since you are lacking a little, Jace's Ingenuity and Opportunity are both great at instant speed and really net a lot of cards for the investment. Mind Spring is really good since it can dig so deep late game. Think Twice Catalog Artificer's Epiphany Tragic Lesson all instant speed and most do not require a discard.

CaptSillva on

5 months ago

River Kelpie, Frost Titan, Grave Titan, and Inferno Titan are all great options for this deck.

Also Identity Thief is quite interesting because of the way this game treats replacement effects. In case you don't know. If a card tells you to exile it when it would leave play, this replacement effect will only trigger if the card in question is going somewhere other than exile. So if exile an unearthed card with a card effect, your effect will override the unearth effect since the card is already being exiled.

PickleNutz on red blue control for the Dominus

5 months ago

Maybe cut 2 Serum Visions and replace with counters like Mana Leak, cut Glen Elendra Archmage completely and grab Snapcaster Mage, Cut Dominus of Fealty for Eidolon of the Great Revel, grab some dual search lands and dual searchable lands Scalding Tarn, Steam Vents, or even the new cycle land from Amonkhet, cut Identity Thief for either incenerate or another burn spell, cut 2 lands for extra counters now because the CMC of the deck would drop dramatically and it would improve 100%, though it wouldn't even be close to the original. Without most of that though, in modern especially, it won't go so well in tournament play. Good luck either way.

Load more