Whenever a creature attacks you, its controller loses 1 life.
Price & Acquistion Set Price Alerts
Hissing Miasma Discussion
4 days ago
MegaMatt13, as far as the Norn's Annex, Marchesa's Decree, Hissing Miasma, Blood Reckoning question goes, it was somewhat of a difficult question. None of them are great Pillow Fort or Rattlesnake cards, and even Norn's Annex remains on the chopping block. They do less than they should. The loss of life can add up, but I have found that inhibiting the development of board state or causing loss of card or permanent resources is more of a disincentive than small life loss. Life is treated as a resource that can be spent, and people do choose to spend it. When choosing, I considered the CMC of Norn's Annex to be plus 4 life, with the option to pay to reduce that life loss. The loss of 2 life is twice as effective as teh loss of 1 life, so that made a difference. On top of that, I actually would rather that they paid , because that inhibits their development. Either way, the resource demand of Norn's Annex is way larger than that of the others. I also find that Queen Marchesa is the only Monarch card needed, so I devalued that ability. If one were to use all of these cards, I could see it becoming a huge Rattlesnake wall, where one would be paying 4+ life per attack, but that would take at lease 3 cards to achieve, and I find that needing + mana to attack is actually harder to overcome than 5+ life. The mana resource is a steeper cost than the life resource.
6 days ago
TheRedGoat and RedJokr, I'm not sure why I didn't consider Crosis, the Purger already. But as far as being a hate commander, do you think Crosis, the Purger or Thraximundar is better? Based on the way I built this, I'm not sold on Marchesa, the Black Rose because, as TheRedGoat saod, there is no synergy.
TheRedGoat what would you take out for Blood Artist or the other? My problem with them is generally they are targeted before anyone board wipes, and they are generally ineffective. I've taken Blood Artist out of so many edh decks for that reason. Plus, Hissing Miasma is harder to destroy.
Also TheRedGoat, what synergies would you like to add in?
1 week ago
Okay, I like how you've expanded on greed to be about mainly opponents who try to overuse their cards. And focusing the "envy hate" cards to be just flat out stopping the envious player that wants to be destructive is cool. But I'm afraid you've now got the problem of too many hate cards versus any kind of synergy with your commander of choice (Marchesa).
I'm glad you mentioned that I helped you fine tune how to punish each sin, but I think now you'll need to remove some of the cards you're using to make space for other synergies in the deck that may end up having you commit the very sins you're trying to punish. Which technically you already are with your current build, but anyway.
If you want to stick with Marchesa, the Black Rose, then you'll need space for more +1/+1 counter synergies. Keeping it simple for now I think Unspeakable Symbol can do a good chunk of the work, but I'm at a loss as of yet where you could cut for it. And that is assuming you are keeping Marchesa as the commander and would need such synergies.
I will say that I feel Ugin, the Spirit Dragon is better left out and you put the Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker you already have in his place. In my eyes any of his effects are exactly meant to look the most powerful player in the eye, and only them, and say "you're dead". The prideful player more than the envious or gluttonous one is most deserving of that ultimate. They are the one you reduce to nothing and make humble as an example to others.
I can also suggest that instead of maybe the Hissing Miasma card at least you could run Blood Artist or even Falkenrath Noble as a sort of punishment towards players who become the destructive type of wrath (which coincides with envy) and you can then punish that player for each creature they just killed. Arcbond to me can work in a similar way but be considered a pride hate card as well.
I'll have to do some researching/testing for the rest of the deck, but let me know if that works for you so far.
TLDR: you so far have made a "hate bear" deck but without the bear part. Maybe try Crosis, the Purger for commander?
1 month ago
i think your deck might need a little bit of work still; here's some suggestions
hope that helps :)
1 month ago
- Samut, Voice of Dissent (good gruul beats, plus I have one and want to try it out)
- Bloodghast (great engine for sacrifice decks, but maybe too good. no other deck wants it, so... i dunno. thoughts?)
- Sunblast Angel (mass removal that won't kill everything)
- Phyrexian Revoker (I think we need this kind of effect)
- Karlov of the Ghost Council (decent Orzhov beater? maybe too build-around)
- Treasury Thrull (recurs all pieces for Orzhov drain)
- Authority of the Consuls (Blind obedience #2)
- Polluted Bonds (cross-archetype card that punishes fetches big time)
- Ayli, Eternal Pilgrim (could be interesting)
- Vampire Nighthawk (good black beats)
- Hissing Miasma (could be interesting?)
- Blood Baron of Vizkopa (nice beater, on theme)
- Suture Priest (on theme)
1 month ago
If you're looking to ensure that other people don't attack you, I would recommend the following
1 month ago
Sweet deck, man!