|Have (98)||cryptoplasm , Seyge , vollrath , kyuuri117 , DukeNicky , rathershabby , lotusofblackness , gnarlycore , bmgworldgaming , NoisyPotato , tekidi1 , scare983 , Putrefy , StarkCybernetics , CommanderOfBolas , commodorecanary , paulc5190 , WingsLDK , avatarofdiscord , guerillarage , Netherziel , baeu0003 , Baycer , TheHorse , JMMC , SuperSalamander , clockworkcactus , Mutt5258 , EthanGlover1 , cdodgers , BroncosFan18 , Nines19 , jeveland392 , KULiiA , Amplify91 , Syhiver , Azuleblood , Represser , Danielsworlds , mckin , hoki , Makki2chigi , Zackalot , sblay1 , crazywhiteboydance , HalcyonMTG , monkJ444 , slagathor3 , UnbornValkyrie , jpae , AlbinoLion , LioAME3 , McSleuthburger , lucyfarrell , Carsf , jkweaver , muppetgamer , BacktraF , Kylethon , B1ITZ3D , Manicton123 , StarflashSoar , REV666 , BoshJurke , crimsonwolfzro , cleviticus , phoenixed , NuBByThuMB , veritates1 , DovahWalrus , thecaleb , multiplayer , TrystonSpencer , Jlintelman , Treyseph , Fatred , DSHoyt , rmorrissey99 , wtrob , Carnin , DrVendetta , BiggRedd54 , Theplusone , Alliii1022 , CampbellStev , Butters01 , noahband , notsodeadpool , XxiSupaL3GACYxX , problackknight , mziter501 , bdal , CrazyLittleGuy , Fleetfiend , bigguy99 , kescher , Erathis , webdokkeren|
|Want (66)||MUTEDM1ND , musselhead , Draygo , blackdragonetm , 8vomit , Sauron_ , artakha , JdogCT , rmorrissey99 , GoldGhost012 , bradyofportdetroit , corruptgargoyle , Maximusx27 , NoOneYouKnow , Myythic666 , EridanWwins , colonelpopcorn , Execut1ve , ZooGambler , tazartheyoot , wsurugby10 , MrEggCream , RobT , dbp512 , VampireArmy , Thire , pattertj , gododoom9 , PartyGoat , swampertman8 , slagathor3 , shinobigarth , redafroninja , RubyStrings , BlooShinja , DobeNode , Dremi , Geoman911 , RealityShock , Ryethe , SilentArbiter , FizzatzHaderach , fuckin_martians , wavemaster92 , AlucardZain , Arashisenko , metljoe , TheGreatSeamus , maiden77 , Xwright , Ashigaru7 , Caligula , tj70 , SniperElGato , sraid , Doom_of_Valyria , jaredscottwilson , Jakebartley , soulwarden11 , jrgoudie , dnota , Haxxzor1 , Orcrin12 , MisterMayhem , eeriekiller , Virlym|
Neat idea, I'd focus more on the Constellation aspect though.
I would recommend drop 1 Nykthos and add 1 Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth to even out the field for yourself a little?
Also, I know its built on Waste Not but I highly recommend dropping it to 2-3 in standard just because there is no way to really fuel its abilities right now. (They discard a few, and play rest of their cards, so no hand = no effects).
And Liliana Vess is great because she can be continuous discard as well as Fetching for you if you need it. Why no Hero's Downfall? Or at least Bile Blight for annoying drops or flyers (In particular, Mantis Rider )
Rune-Scarred Demon is fantastic and something you should put in, maybe Baneslayer Angel because she is really good. For the manabase Sacred Foundry? Maybe the fetches if you have budget for them. I don't really think Holy Day, Lightning Bolt or Redeem the Lost have a place in EDH. Maybe try Murder or Hero's Downfall or Vindicate depending on your budget. Swords to Plowshares is another card I would add and I would up the land base to at least 36 adding in Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth. Just some suggestions +1
I would definitely not use Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx if you are wanting to use Bile Blight and Sign in Blood. This will cause MANY situations which will cause you to not be able to cast either of these spells on turn two if you need to.
I do think that you may be a just a little heavy on removal, and light on permanents. I would probably cut one Hero's Downfall and one Murderous Cut, adding in another Whip of Erebos and another Herald of Torment. This will give you a couple more permanents, and allow you to draw Whip of Erebos twice as often. With all of the self-inflicted pain you are going to cause yourself with your lands and spells, you will want the extra lifegain potential. Gary can't handle it all by himself.
Traded a Siege Rhino, Dig Through Time, Hero's Downfall and 2 Battlefield Forge for 2 Archangel of Thune. No regrets, because Archangel will maintain value, while the others will drop to oblivion, except Dig, which will sit nicely around $6.
Having multiple cards that essentially do the same thing limits the flexibility of your deck to react. Utility in the SB means having 1 card cover certain threats or tactics (if you have multiple that cover a specific one, take it out so you can put in a card to cover a different threat). Setessan Tactics and Savage Punch do the same thing: force fights.
I suggested Arbor Colossus because I think it's better than Bassara Tower Archer in here. Yes Archer has hexproof but if you are just playing it to wait to make a fat Reverent Hunter then you cannot use it because pretty much anything he blocks will kill him without Aspect of Hydra (which you only have 2 of so drawing it will be slim already). If you ramped into a Colossus he can block nearly anything all day, has more devotion, and monstrosity.
At the end of the day it's your deck so do what will make you excited and happy to play it.
|3.33 TIX||4.2 TIX|
|Avg. draft pick||2.2|
|Avg. cube pick||1.87|
|Commander / EDH||Legal|