Gideon's Reproach

Legality

Format Legality
Tiny Leaders Legal
Limited Legal
Frontier Legal
Vintage Legal
Modern Legal
Highlander Legal
Block Constructed Legal
Standard Legal
Legacy Legal
1v1 Commander Legal
Duel Commander Legal
Casual Legal
Unformat Legal
Pauper Legal
Commander / EDH Legal

Printings View all

Set Rarity
Battle for Zendikar (BFZ) Common

Combos Browse all

Gideon's Reproach

Instant

Gideon's Reproach deals 4 damage to target attacking or blocking creature.

Price & Acquistion Set Price Alerts

BFZ

Ebay

Have (5) hosshughes , frederiklw , Atroxreaper , Tommuz , KB2187
Want (0)

Recent Decks

Load more

Gideon's Reproach Discussion

OminousRex on White Devils (Ixalan Vampire Weenies)

5 days ago

I might add Gideon's Reproach to the SB since mardu vehicles is a thing and in testing, he is a particular annoyance.

oekan on Red-White Exert

1 month ago

I built a deck with the same theme you should give it a look RW Exert. I would up the lands to at least 21. I found myself stuck with 2 lands for a long time when I tested below 21. Maybe ditch the artifacts for Always Watching its a great card and lets you exert without a penalty. I would also swap out Gideon's Reproach for Abrade can still kill creatures and also destroy annoying artifacts if you need to. Running Glorybringer is something to look at it is one of the best finishers in standard right now.

BioProfDude on Exerted White

4 months ago

Interesting deck. Instead of Immolating Glare, I would suggest Gideon's Reproach as it can get an attacking or blocking creature. It's better than Impeccable Timing in that it deals 1 more damage. Also, Blessed Alliance might be good.

I have a similar deck that might give you some ideas? Maybe not, but might be worth a look. White weenie extraordinaire

+1 from me!

herringtonr on

4 months ago

I would HIGHLY recommend putting a second a in the title. Also, add a few Qasali Pridemages to deal with Ensnaring Bridge and other cards like that. Instead of Gideon's Reproach, I would recommend Smite as it does the same job better since you can declare its block, then exile it at the damage step without the creature taking damage. Qasali Ambusher can also be an amazing combat trick to deal with a Goblin Guide. I would cut one White Sun's Zenith in favor of another Asceticism to make the chance to draw it more consistant.

JBert on Gideon Tribal

4 months ago

Not enough Gideon. Consider adding the following: Gideon's Intervention Gideon's Reproach Gideon's Resolve Oath of Gideon

There are also more cards that feature Gideon in the art and Flavor text.

OOBS on Monowhite Humans Deck

5 months ago

Have you considered replacing Whitesun's Passage with Rest for the Weary? Also, I'd consider replacing Gideon's Reproach with a way to recover/last against control decks, as control (specifically the wrath effects) is hard for white weenie/mono white humans to deal with. Ranger of Eos could be very helpful for recovering on board. Good luck with the brew!

kellerke83 on Trample and the invisible blocker

5 months ago

I know the strange rule where if an opponent declares attackers and I declare blockers then sacrifice the creature that i was blocking with the damage is still considered blocked. Or if in a similar situation I declare blockers and the creature is destroyed the damage is also still blocked. However I'm curious how the trample ability would interact in this situation for example if I am attacking with a 4-4 with trample and my opponent blocks with a 4-3 then before damage is dealt I play Gideon's Reproach and destroy his blocker how will damage then be dealt and please site rules if you don't mind.

Load more