|Commander / EDH||Legal|
Printings View all
|New Phyrexia (NPH)||Uncommon|
Combos Browse all
Artifact Creature — Wall
DefenderWhen Cathedral Membrane is put into a graveyard from the battlefield during combat, it deals 6 damage to each creature it blocked this combat.
Price & Acquistion Set Price Alerts
Cathedral Membrane Discussion
2 months ago
Since the secondary ability of Wall of Forgotten Pharaohs only works with deserts and I'm trying to modernize this deck, I found some potential replacements, as there's no point in including slow lands for a single creature.
- Steel Wall
- Oona's Gatewarden
- Perimeter Captain
- Order of the Stars
- Consulate Skygate
- Wall of Tanglecord
- Cathedral Membrane
- Thing in the Ice Flip
- Returned Phalanx
- Murmuring Phantasm
- Ludevic's Test Subject Flip
- Kaijin of the Vanishing Touch
- Jeskai Barricade
- Geist of the Lonely Vigil
- Fog Bank
- Angelic Wall
- Vertigo Spawn
- Wall of Omens
- Wall of Essence
I really like Kaijin of the Vanishing Touch because of how bouncing enemy threats is a big theme of this deck, but I could also see Thing in the Ice Flip being a replacement for both Wall of Forgotten Pharaohs as well as Striped Riverwinder though it doesn't get Hexproof. Thoughts, comments, suggestions?
4 months ago
BAAAABE, Aegis Automaton, Augmenting Automaton, Cathedral Membrane, Darklit Gargoyle for artifact creatures.Brain Maggot, Aegis of the Gods, Gnarled Scarhide, Hopeful Eidolon, Nyx-Fleece Ram, Spiteful Returned for enchantment creatures. :) Love you!
6 months ago
Because I have 0 of them, else I'd play a set :D. The Cathedral Membranes work somewhat and stop big creatures in combat, but that draw would save me when my hand empties. They are my priority to find for the deck!
7 months ago
Glad I could help, interested to see where the deck will go once you start playing around with it.
That being said, you're kinda running low on lands, if you want to drop a 5 drop on t5 consistently. I think you could be greedy and get away with playing 23 total, but even then you're still off the "correct" number of 25 (with the average cmc of 2.75, explained here). Should you ajust the manabase, think we could get away with a few more non-basics, if you're interested. Rogue's Passage can help get the big flyer through to seal the win, Ghost Quarter or the slightly worse Tectonic Edge can help shut down enemy lands or take decks off of colours completely, Moorland Haunt lets you recycle the dead walls into a potent, ghost-based airforce. Minamo, School at Water's Edge while worth a large sum of money, is a potent combination with Ojutai, should you choose to run a few more, the similarly pricey Celestial Colonnade can also help wreck face late in the game, but neither of the two are necessary by any means.
Wall of Omens really shines in this regard, the more cards you see in a game, the more likely you are to win. I think the overall quality of Wall/Defender creatures you are looking to play is bit low. Cathedral Membrane is one mana(dont be afraid to spend life, life is a resource to be used) and usually EXPLODES the creature unfortunate enough to be blocked by it. Dragon's Eye Sentry is pretty damn good for just 1 mana, and really highlights how bad cards like Nearheath Pilgrim (2/1s always die in combat, 2 mana is far too expensive for a card that trades with most 1/1s) are. If it's a card you love, keep it, but you could be playing MUCH better cards. Jeskai Barricade can swoop in and save one of the beaters if they should lose hexproof, let you perfectly block a massive creature(without trample) by bouncing the creature blocking it before damage or just bounce Wall of Omens for that tasty, tasty value.
If you were to run a few more Ojutai, Orator of Ojutai is a better Wall of Omens, but 4 dragons probably isnt enough, might want to research that. Stalwart Shield-Bearers makes all the walls defenders bigger, Wall of Essence has reverse lifelink, while Vertigo Spawn and its big brother Wall of Frost pin down any creature foolish enough to attack into them. And as big and seemingly unkillable as Wall of Frost is, no wall stands close to the mighty, infuriating Wall of Denial.
Here's a list of all the UW walls available in modern.
Also, I'm a little confused by the Authority of the Consuls and the Swiftfoot Boots. Authority gaining you life is neat, but your deck lays down tricky/large walls, you don't need an enchantment to slow the opponent down. What creature are the boots for, exactly? Overseer and Ojutai have hexproof, as does Shieldmate(most likely). These guys dont need haste because they come in protected and swing in later. So all we're really protecting is our disposable walls/defenders, Elspeth tokens and Nearheath Pilgrim, who isn't an incredible magic card. Boots also costing 2 mana kinda gums up the works; you want to be doing something every turn, ideally. Spending two mana on a card that needs a addition one mana to actually do anything on any turn between 2-5 doesnt seem like an awesome time.
Speaking of Elspeth, Elspeth, Sun's Champion sees great as an option if you find yourself facing a lot of big creatres; she can get rid of them while leaving your defenders in pristine condition to... defend.
Witchbane Orb feels like a sideboard card for when you're really getting beaten down by burn or Thoughtseize-style effects, and even then, those types of cards are usually cheap, so waiting til turn 4 to:
A. defend yourself from 1-2 mana spells and B. Do nothing on turn 4
doesnt seem like the greatest plan, IMO. Keep it in the Sideboard if its a card you like, by all means.
That's enough wall talk for now, 3am, must sleep.
7 months ago
Remember that I gain life with extort and can get protection and Cathedral Membrane get some solid defence
8 months ago
+1 Nice deck!
T1: land, Viscera Seer
So a couple things:
I think you should up Eldritch Evolution to 4.
Play fewer lands that come into play tapped and more black and green.
(Maybe consider abandoning blue for black discard & tutor to even out the mana? taking out Yavimaya Coast for a split between Caves of Koilos or Blooming Marsh)
That's all I got.
Good luck and nice deck again!
1 year ago
Harvest Hand Flip, Cathedral Membrane, Cauldron of Souls, Clone Shell, Epochrasite, Filigree Familiar, Hangarback Walker, Junk Diver, Lifeline, Myr Retriever, Myr Sire, Salvaging Station, Solemn Simulacrum, Su-Chi, Sylvok Lifestaff, Wingrattle Scarecrow, Workshop Assistant, Batterskull, Colfenor's Urn, Myr Servitor, Nim Deathmantle, Sanctum Gargoyle, Scrapheap Scrounger, Spine of Ish Sah, Ichor Wellspring, and Whip of Erebos are all on my list for this Commander, as well as quite a few you have here!