|Commander / EDH||Legal|
Printings View all
|Eternal Masters (EMA)||Common|
|Vintage Masters (VMA)||Common|
Combos Browse all
Creature — Human Cleric
Sacrifice Benevolent Bodyguard: Target creature you control gains protection from the color of your choice until end of turn.
|Have (4)||Joblaska , mziter501 , ahobrien , voidruby|
|Want (15)||BringerOfStorms , DeadeyeDesperado , Korevana , doonmeister , Dawnbreaker7727 , sycdan , vakuso , Cheshire000 , DragynFyre , Fralaylah , 0ur0b0r05 , Arrownight , AzureOctive , Turtlelover73 , powertrot|
Benevolent Bodyguard Discussion
2 weeks ago
DrkNinja: Honestly, I'm running Samurai of the Pale Curtain because I already had a foil, and it has some of my favorite typing in the game... Lol. Honestly I should probably be running both? At least she can carry a sword if I need to deal damage.
With regards to your other suggestions, Ethersworn Canonist DEFINITELY should be on my maybeboard. I feel like Loxodon Gatekeeper is kinda too much mana for his effect, have you found it to be very strong? Tithe Taker is a less-good Grand Abolisher (who honestly should be in here, but cuts are hard...).
Darkshadow327: I've never run Bygone Bishop before, but I feel like he'd be rather good at dodging effects like Spirit of the Labyrinth , and the VAST majority of my creature spells are CMC 3 or less. I'm curious about testing him at least!
hkhssweiss: Gift of Immortality was the MVP of my older Avacyn version, because it let me repeatedly sacrifice cards like Benevolent Bodyguard . However, I have less of those cards in this version, so it doubles as protection for my hatebears... I'm not sure if it's as good here.
Thanks everyone! If you like my Avacyn list, I'd ask that you upvote the "original" (Judgment Day: Avacyn the Purifier EDH | *PRIMER*) rather than this temporary version ;)
2 months ago
I love cleric tribal, I realize this is a jank deck but with some focus it can also be effective. I think the first trick is to synergize with your command and find clerics that can be sacrificed for gains the second is to find ways to drain their health quickly so you can focus on the first.
The next one is not quite so easy and needs tuning to make really good, but I would recommend clerics like Benevolent Bodyguard, Children of Korlis, Dark Supplicant with Scion of Darkness, Frontline Medic, Nova Cleric, Remorseful Cleric, Sanctum Guardian and Selfless Spirit for creatures that can be utilized well with your commander and as a bonus its flavorful to have fanatical priests dedicated to some grim god.
I don't know if you will continue to develop this but I would like to see your take on it as you evolve it.
3 months ago
So as a fellow player of Renegade Freighter I'm happy to call this one of the coolest new takes on the idea for vehicles. The exalted really helps push damage through and you seem pretty capable of being a real threat even without vehicles. Mobile Garrison is also intersting as it help defend, but I feel as though it could be a dead card if you already have a Frieghter out and attacking, but whether you agree or not with that is fine.
However I'd say that you should think about Kami of False Hope or Holy Day instead of Fog in the sideboard as you seem to have more white than green mana sources. Additionally I would run either Natural State or Fragmentize over Caustic Caterpillar unless you want to keep the creature to help crew vehicles. Also I would consider a few other ideas:
Sideboard Change Reccomendations: 2 Holy Day or Kami of False Hope, 2 Fragmentize or Natural State, 2 Gods Willing or Benevolent Bodyguard or Apostle's Blessing, 3 Mana Leak or Dispell or Vapor Snag, 3 Spell Pierce, 3 Life Goes On,
Mana Leak is a good card, but if your using three colours you'll probably want to use as efficent spells as possible such as Dispell; and Vapor Snag is also a good way to stop irritating creatures and is a favorite of mine but Mana leak is still good so keep it if you like it. But mana efficency is also why I reccomend Apostle's Blessing as it can cast with any colour; and as a side note Benevolent Bodyguard can crew vehicles which is relevent, which is also applicable to my recomendation for Kami of False Hope.
I know this may seem like a lot of stuff to reccomend but I love your deck concept and I'd love to see it improve! Cheers and have fun out there!
5 months ago
Phantom General probably isn't worth running. Kheru Bloodsucker isn't very good, you don't have many things to trigger it. Geist-Honored Monk is okay, but doesn't really fit into what you're trying to do. Doomed Dissenter is okay as sacrifice fodder, but that's all he does. Not a huge fan of the instant / sorcery spells except for Bone Splinters.
Children of Korlis is a cool human that can sac itself ot trigger Xathrid and its effect negates damage for a turn. Benevolent Bodyguard can be sac'd to save one of your important guys from removal, like Xathrid; and he's also a human to trigger the effect.
6 months ago
I STRONGLY recommend a couple Standard Bearers in the side or even the main. Enchantment stacking is just asking to get you crushed by spot removal, and while stacking protection is nice, it's not a long-term solution, especially if your opponent is heavily control.
Speaking of protection, a couple Sejiri Steppe instead of Plains would be great for utility.
In a deck like this, I'd worry about running out of gas, so I think you could stand to add a couple Pentarch Wards to cantrip/replace.
Cool list! :D
7 months ago
Always cool to see another heroes build! If I may suggest though, I find that Benevolent Bodyguard tends to be worse than something like, say, Emerge Unscathed as while it does require keeping a mana open it can take the opponent by surprise (and in this case can create another heroic trigger next turn). I generally find playing the effect at instant speed works better, but I can also see the benefit of another body, so I guess it's all about preference.
8 months ago
chizmo9: Feeling of Dread is a good suggestion, because of the flashback, thanks. The only reason I might stick with Lyev Decree instead is because it stops Activated Abilities also. So, something like Llanowar Augur or Benevolent Bodyguard would be rendered useless by Lyev Decree, while Feeling of Dread would allow the abilities to still be used.
I may be being too paranoid though, so when I get a chance I'll playtest and see. Thanks again!
9 months ago
Not sure about Land Grant. In combo deck, you really don't want show your opponent that you have all pieces in hand. Second suggestion is Benevolent Bodyguard, its cheaper than apostle blessing when on battlefield.
Benevolent Bodyguard occurrence in decks from the last year
Commander / EDH:
All decks: 0.01%