|Commander / EDH||Legal|
Printings View all
|Mercadian Masques (MMQ)||Common|
Combos Browse all
Creature — Human Mercenary
Whenever Alley Grifters becomes blocked, defending player discards a card.
Alley Grifters Discussion
4 months ago
cmsrDPM To answer each of your points:
"1 I pretend WOTC will see this one day and care."
Why is that a parameter for the card creation? I mean, most card creation is based on a probability that the card might see print. At least that's what I think is the foundation for the Custom Cards subforum. I guess I just mean; isn't that a given?
"2 Wizards is very particular about white getting card advantage and why."
They are particular in not granting white straight card advantage, such as play spell; draw multiple cards or activate ability; draw card.
But it's not like white haven't gotten card advantage before (you mention Mentor of the Meek yourself and I can boot with Dawn of Hope .) It just mostly happens on a condition. This aura is pretty conditional, which is why I believe it could be printed stronger than what you suggested.
First of all it is an aura for creatures. You're already lining yourself up to get 2-for-1'ed, as is the pinnacle of weaknesses of auras.
Second of all it only triggers on declare blockers. Your opponent is in control of the accessibility of that card draw (unless you can provoke the condition or something else forces the opponent's hand). If you get to draw a card, that's because your opponent allowed you to. It is similar in nature to red's punisher-mechanic like Browbeat . Whenever you put the choice into your opponent's hands, it is always a worse effect.
"As I mentioned in the original there are some creatures that can block many things"
The wording on my suggestion is a singular trigger. "Whenever enchanted creature blocks or becomes blocked, draw a card." No matter how many creatures you block, there's only one trigger. If I had put "Whenever enchanted creature blocks a creature or becomes blocked by a creature", it would count multiple times.
See ruling on a card like Alley Grifters .
And as said previously; my wording enables creatures without power.
"4 I wanted to mirror Curiosity ."
But Curiosity has that ever-so-crucial lack of combat damage. Anyway, it's fair enough. You wanted to create something that was more safe. But that's where I personally deviate from your viewpoint. If I were to look at cards, I would rather that they be interesting; either in design/mechanic, power or flavor.
Not to be a naysayer, but I think this would be a bin-card, at least the original printing - the revised version by PlayswithFIRE is remarkably better but IMO still on the weaker side. Not that there's anything wrong with bin-cards, but I think R&D can cook up plenty of bin-cards all by themselves.
I'm more interested (personally) in chasing the challenge of a fair but powerful card design. I would rather create something that I think would be used if printed, rather than making sure it has a higher chance of being printed.
11 months ago
Looks like Alley Grifters is breastfeeding someone lol
1 year ago
You have to choose the creature before the blockers are decleared, so having evasive creatures with haste will work better than trample, and maybe use creatures that if arent blocked will have some kind of effect or the other way araund.
and probably add mass remuval and normal remuval.
sorry if all the cards i listed are black, im just more familiar with it.
No data for this card yet.